Insulation with polyurethane foam - pros and cons, reviews

Slowly, but Russians are still saying goodbye to small-sized apartments in Khrushchev-era buildings, where a 3-room apartment is often smaller in area than a modern one-room apartment. More and more large private houses are appearing. At the same time, we are talking not only about cottages in elite villages. As the living space increases, heating costs also increase. Proper thermal insulation of all structural elements of a building can save household finances, and therefore homeowners approach the choice of insulation very responsibly. After all, the slightest mistake is fraught with unpleasant consequences in the future.

Taking into account the increased attention of consumers to the topic of thermal insulation materials, the editors of the StroyGuru website have prepared a series of articles about modern types of insulation materials, their characteristics, advantages and disadvantages, and the best manufacturers. In this work we will tell you everything about polyurethane foam insulation, its liquid version, which among builders is called for short - polyurethane foam.

What is polyurethane foam

A new type of insulation for Russia, polyurethane foam, is rapidly expanding its niche in the construction market. Poor knowledge of the characteristics of the material, aggressive advertising by manufacturers and anti-advertising of competitors have led to the fact that this material is full of myths and conjectures, among which not only ordinary consumers, but also professional builders are lost.

This is what foamed two-component polyurethane looks like.

The problems start with terminology. By polyurethane foam insulation, many understand foam rubber, familiar to everyone from childhood. But this is a soft and very elastic type of polyurethane foam, which can be used to insulate entrance doors in a building, but not structural elements. Real insulation is in liquid form.

But even here, consumers and experts make inaccuracies, considering simple polyurethane foam to be the same as polyurethane foam insulation. At first glance, they are right: both materials are made of polyurethane foam. But there is still a significant difference. PPU insulation consists of two components: “A” - polyol and “B” - polyisocyanate. When mixed, they enter into a polymer synthesis reaction with the release of carbon dioxide. The result is a foamed material with a rigid structure and closed cells. Polyurethane foam can be purchased in barrels or pre-filled cylinders.

Polyurethane foam consists of one component, which, when exposed to air, comes into contact with water vapor (which is why there is a recommendation to wet the surface before applying foam) and polymerizes with oxygen, creating open cells of frozen foam. Hence the completely different physical and technical indicators. To make it clear what we are talking about, we present a table with the main characteristics of the materials.

Table 1. Main indicators of polyurethane foam and polyurethane foam.

One type of polyurethane foam is polyurethane foam.

The next myth is that the insulation is new, little studied. Therefore, it is better to give preference to a well-tested, albeit not the best, heat insulator.

Indeed, in Russia this type of insulation began to be used only in the mid-90s of the last century. It is finding its niche with difficulty, since consumers still prefer traditional insulation materials: expanded clay, glass wool and basalt fiber wool.

The late appearance of PPU in the CIS countries does not at all mean that it appeared in the countries of Europe and North America at the same time. There it has been known since the late 30s of the 20th century (invented by the German chemist Otto von Bayer). Today, the lion's share of the insulation market in the USA and Europe is occupied by two-component polyurethane foam.

Characteristics

There is also no clarity about the characteristics of the material.

Thermal conductivity

When advertising their products, sellers indicate very low thermal conductivity values ​​of polyurethane foam. Rarely, you can find a coefficient of 0.017 W/(m×°K), more often - 0.020-0.022 W/(m×°K). But this is from the realm of fantasy. Even in laboratory conditions, where all requirements for the quality of components and their formulation can be met, it is rarely possible to obtain a thermal conductivity index of 0.022 W/(m×°K).

Similar values ​​are achieved only with the use of freon r141b as a foaming agent, which is prohibited for use in Europe (and therefore is not produced). The use of other foaming agents increases the value of the coefficient, and therefore in European countries a thermal insulation layer with a thermal conductivity of 0.028 W/(m×°K) is considered high quality.

In Russia, the real figures are 0.030-0.035 W/(m×°K) (the specific value depends on the experience of the performers).

However, consumers should not be upset. Even if the technology is violated, the actual thermal conductivity of the insulation deserves respect, since it is one of the best and comparable to basalt wool.

Density

The density of the insulation determines the bending strength (fragility), the weight load on the structure and the thermal insulation properties.

Two-component, closed-cell polyurethane foam, can be obtained in different densities, combined into 3 groups.

• 1 group. Low density - 28-32 kg/m3. The main scope of application is ceilings and walls from inside the room, onto which the material is applied in a thin layer. Thermal conductivity coefficient is from 0.028 to 0.032 W/(m×°K). Vapor permeability at the wood level is 0.05 mg/(m*h*Pa), which makes it possible, albeit conditionally, after detailed calculations, to use polyurethane foam for insulating the walls of wooden houses (more on the problem below).
• 2nd group. Average density - 32-40 kg/m3. A classic representative of the species. The components are sold separately, in cylinders. Used to insulate all structural elements of a building. It has the lowest percentage of moisture absorption among all types of insulation.
• 3rd group. High density - 40-80 kg/m3. Achieving such density using portable equipment is theoretically possible, but practically impossible. It is used in places with high mechanical load on the heat-insulating layer, but only after special surface treatment, which experts call armoring.

Life time

Manufacturers of polyurethane foam consider their products to be durable, with a service life of 30-50 years. These figures are confirmed by the experience of using this insulation in the USA and Europe. However, in Russia, in the first years of using the new product, they were faced with the fact that the insulation from the facades of multi-storey buildings began to fall off in layers after 5-6 years of operation.

At first, the root of the evil was seen in the poor adhesion of polyurethane foam to the wall material. When the lag became widespread, they began to study the problem seriously and turned to Western experience. It turned out that the reason is in a completely different plane - the sun's rays. The material does not tolerate ultraviolet irradiation, ages, or in the language of scientists: it is subject to UV destruction. The aging rate is about 1 mm per year.

The worst enemy of polyurethane foam is the sun.

Simply painting the insulating layer with fade-resistant paint or mastic protects the material from destruction, extending its service life to 30 years when the facade is open. If the insulated facade is finished with siding or porcelain stoneware, you don’t have to worry about the safety of the insulation at all.

Adhesion

Foamed polyurethane has excellent adhesion to all types of building materials, with the exception of polyethylene film. For example, in order to tear polymerized insulation from concrete, you will have to apply a force of at least 2.5 kg/cm2, and for steel - 1.5 kg/m2. These are very large numbers. No wonder the best types of glue are polyurethane based. But such adhesion is possible only if the insulation is sprayed onto a clean and dry surface.

The insulation will not adhere to whitewash and “boiling” plaster; it will fall off along with them under minor mechanical loads due to low bending strength.

How to prepare the attic from the inside for foam insulation

The insulation process begins with preparatory activities. All foreign objects are removed from the attic. Firstly, they will get in the way. Secondly, stuck foam is difficult to remove. Expensive tools, furniture and other valuable items may be damaged.

Peeling paint and other old finishes are removed before insulating the attic elements

After freeing up the space, they begin to prepare the surface where polyurethane foam is sprayed. The peeling paint is cleaned off with a spatula. If there is old insulation or decrepit cladding, dismantle everything and get rid of dust. Wooden roof elements are inspected for integrity. Damaged beams are replaced or repaired.

The attic has windows. They are all covered with film, along with window sills and slopes. It is difficult to remove foam that gets onto an unprotected area without a trace, so you will have to try with a reliable shelter.

Advantages and disadvantages

The most controversial question among specialists and consumers is: what are the pros and cons of polyurethane foam insulation. This is where there are many myths and speculations.

Let's first consider the positive aspects that are beyond doubt. This:

• high thermal insulation properties - the insulation has one of the best thermal conductivity indicators;
• durability - service life of at least 30 years;
• good adhesion to all types of wall materials;
• no seams - the insulation is sprayed onto a continuous carpet, resulting in no cold bridges;
• environmental friendliness of the material - problems exist only at the moment of application, when carbon dioxide is released during the chemical reaction. After polymerization is completed, polyurethane foam becomes completely safe, since it contains no volatile components;

Polyurethane foam is an environmentally friendly product.

• self-extinguishing - does not support the combustion process;
• light weight, which does not create serious loads on the building structure;
• Possibility of application to the most complex geometric surfaces;
• low level of water absorption. Among insulation materials - the undisputed leader;
• shows inertness to almost all substances used at the household level;
• does not serve as a basis for the reproduction of microorganisms;
• wide temperature range in which operation is possible - from -160 to +150oC;
• versatility - you can insulate the outside and inside of a building, attic, walls, floor and ceiling.

However, among the pros and cons of polyurethane foam insulation, there are also myths .

• Serves as an excellent sound insulator. Having a closed cell structure and low weight, polyurethane foam can neither reflect nor absorb sound waves. Its noise-insulating properties when insulating metal hangars appear for a completely different reason: having stuck to the metal, the material does not allow the latter to resonate. And these are completely different principles of noise suppression, which do not work in apartments and houses.
• Mice and rats do not touch. This conclusion is made based on the fact that the polymer is not digested in the stomach of rodents. But at the same time, one loses sight of the fact that rodents make moves in the insulation with pleasure.
• Using polyurethane foam allows you to save on vapor and waterproofing. Firstly, this statement applies only to high-density materials, and to medium-density materials conditionally. Secondly, when wet during direct contact with water, it takes a very long time to dry. In this case, the statement about resistance against mold and mildew does not work - repeated cases of the appearance of colonies of microorganisms on the surface have been recorded. Thirdly, low vapor permeability becomes a problem with external insulation of cellular materials (gas silicate and aerated concrete blocks) and wooden walls (more on the problem below).
• The process of applying insulation is quick and simple. It's hard to argue about the fast count. Indeed, the insulation time of sprayed polyurethane foam is the shortest compared to other insulation materials. But as for simple technology, it’s a myth. Knowledge and high qualifications are needed, otherwise it will not be possible to apply a layer of insulation that is uniform in thickness and continuous, without seams.

Among the weaknesses :

• intensive aging under the influence of sunlight, which requires mandatory protection of insulation on facades;
• the lack of vapor permeability creates problems when insulating wooden walls and gas-filled blocks from the outside, since the insulation layer shifts the dew point from the thickness of the wall to its surface. Indoors on a frosty day, the humidity level is several times higher. Therefore, the vapor molecules tend to go outside. There is no free outlet - the PPU prevents it. As a result, condensation forms at the junction of the insulation with the wall. The wood decays, foam and gas blocks are destroyed by the formed ice crystals. When insulating walls from the inside, there is no such problem, precisely because of the low vapor permeability of the insulation - moist air from the room is blocked from accessing the dew point, and dry frosty air is not enough for condensation to form;

Insulating wooden walls with polyurethane foam is a dubious method of thermal insulation.

• complex technology, which makes it impossible to insulate polyurethane foam with your own hands;
• lack of resistance against rodents. The material is not a food supply or habitat for mice and rats, but they can easily make passages in it;
• the impossibility of constructing a ventilation gap, which requires complex engineering calculations of the thickness of the sprayed layer - required to remove the dew point from the wall surface;
• the need to use special equipment;
• high cost of material and thermal insulation work;
• the inability to make an accurate calculation of component consumption - even with experienced specialists, the thickness of the thermal layer can vary between 3-8 cm;
• the need to strictly follow the insulation instructions. The slightest deviations lead to a deterioration in the thermal insulation properties of the insulation;
• under compressive loads, thermal conductivity increases sharply.

Application area

Liquid two-component polyurethane foam serves as an excellent insulation material for any structural elements of frame, brick, block and panel buildings, since its low weight does not create serious mechanical loads on house structures, including lightweight ones.

Good adhesion of polyurethane foam with all building materials allows you to spray insulation on vertical and inclined surfaces: facades, roofing, walls inside the house, ceiling. Excellent thermal insulation properties coupled with fairly high moisture resistance make this type of insulation attractive for thermal insulation of country houses, attics, balconies, floors (along joists). Low level of moisture absorption - foundation.

Attention: the use of the material under compressive loads reduces the thermal insulation effect to zero, and therefore polyurethane foam is not sprayed under the screed and “wet facade”.

Polyurethane foam insulation is also used in other industries. It is used to insulate freezers and is sprayed onto pipes of heating systems. Recently, in industrial construction they have begun to use ready-made sheet material for sandwich panels, when liquid polyurethane foam is poured into molds at the factory.

Consumption rates for insulating material per 1m2

When planning a construction budget, you need to accurately determine the amount of material. To determine the amount of liquid insulation that will be required to insulate the entire building, you need to know the consumption rates of penoizol per square meter.

According to manufacturers, the consumption of liquid foam per 1 m2 varies between 1-1.3 liters.

To calculate the required amount of material, you need to multiply the length and width of the wall by the consumption rates stated by the manufacturer. For example: 7*3.2*1.3=29.12 l. In this case, the final amount of thermal insulation must be taken with a small margin, taking into account unforeseen situations.

Manufacturers and prices

Experts call the following companies the best producers of polyurethane foam:

BASF Polyurethanes GmbH. The German company is a leader in the production of polyurethanes. The product line also includes polyurethane foam. In Russia, together with OJSC Nizhnekamskneftekhim, they created the Elastokam enterprise to produce components for polyurethane foam.

Yantai Wanhua Polyurethanes Co., Ltd. Chinese manufacturer with a high-quality line of polyurethane foams.

SYNTHESIA INTERNACIONAL SLU The Spanish chemical company SYNTHESIA INTERNACIONAL SLU has been producing polyurethane foam since 2008. The products have found their buyers in many countries around the world, including Russia.

The price from all manufacturers is about $650 per 1 m3.

Features of equipment for spraying polyurethane foam

The high pressure unit includes:

• A generator, usually powered by a diesel engine.
• Compressor.
• Feed pumps (each component has its own pump).
• The central unit, called the dispenser. The uniform supply of both PU foam components, as well as maintaining the required temperature, depends on it. The unit control unit is installed on the dispenser.
• Spray gun and hoses. The hoses from the compressor to the supply pumps are called supply, and the connecting pumps to the dispenser are called recirculation. The gun also comes with 2 hoses, combined into a common sleeve for ease of use. Direct mixing of the components occurs in the gun.
• Personal protective equipment, which includes a special suit and a respirator. Sometimes the respirator is made in the form of an insulating helmet.

Types of PPU installations

In addition to stable operation and strict maintenance of operating parameters, a good installation should provide protection against bypass resulting in material loss. The cost of equipment that provides high-quality PU foam coating, depending on productivity, ranges from 200 to 800 thousand rubles.

Application technology

The most common method of polyurethane foam insulation is spraying onto the structural elements of the building.

PPU is sprayed onto the walls.

But there is another way - pouring, which requires a space closed on all sides. It is mainly used in factories producing sandwich panels.

Filling with polyurethane foam.

On the floor

Before spraying insulation on the base of the floor, preparatory work is carried out, including: removing the old screed, repairing the concrete base (in a wooden house the subfloor is being restored), waterproofing the ceiling or subfloor. The preparatory process is described in more detail in the material “Preparing the floor for pouring screed.”

A lathing for laminate, parquet, linoleum or joists for floorboards is mounted on the prepared surface. At the same time, both the sheathing slats and the joists should be 20-30 mm higher than the insulation. The gap is necessary to ensure ventilation.

On the walls

The technology for insulating the facade and walls from inside the room is the same. Consists of sequential operations:

1. the old finish is removed from the surface of the walls (you can see how to quickly remove it in the work “Aligning walls for painting”);
2. the sheathing is installed;
3. polyurethane foam is sprayed. In this case, special attention must be paid to corners, crevices and voids;
4. areas with protruding insulation are trimmed with a knife (easy to detect as a rule);
5. Drywall is attached to the sheathing for finishing with wallpaper, painting or decorative plaster.

To the ceiling

Insulation of the PPU ceiling is carried out under a suspended or suspended ceiling. In this case, the old finish is removed from the surface of the floor slab, after which foam is applied in a thin layer (lathing is not required).

On the roof

The roof is one of the few places in the house where you can do polyurethane foam insulation work yourself. To do this, you need to buy special kits with 2 small cylinders and a sprayer. The containers contain the starting reagents, and a sprayer is needed to mix the components. But before starting work, you need to calculate the financial costs so that the roof does not literally turn out to be golden.

Semi-professional kit for PPU insulation.

Preparing the roof for insulation is simple: the surface is dust-free and dried. PPU is applied from the inside between the rafters. After the foam has hardened, the thermal insulation layer is covered with sheets of plywood or OSB.

PPU roof insulation scheme.

The editors of the portal StroyGuru.Com tried to objectively talk about such a controversial insulation material as polyurethane foam. Having complete information about the material, you can make an informed choice and avoid mistakes.

Owner reviews

“I have heard complaints several times that home owners have headaches after insulating them with polyurethane foam. And the smell of the material is not pleasant. These moments are entirely the responsibility of the company that carried out the work. Here it is important to follow the technology and the exact proportions of mixing the components, then there will be no problems.” Victor

“I decided not to deal with complex roofing “pies” and ordered polyurethane foam insulation. The roof and walls of the attic were insulated, and the remainder was used for the garage. Two winters have passed - I am very pleased! Warm, comfortable, no smell. True, I had to tinker with finding craftsmen. Not everyone takes on this kind of work.” Arkady

“After insulation, they forgot to turn on the batteries. We noticed when it got cold outside to 0 degrees. In my opinion, this speaks volumes about quality." Inna